Thrift Stores in & Near Kelleys Island, OH
1 store in Kelleys Island · 2 more within 12 miles · list updated November 5, 2026
Found something at a Kelleys Island thrift store? See what it goes for on eBay
Scan any item in the Spotted app to see what it's listed for on eBay before you buy it. Estate sales, garage sales and store clearance near you are on the same map.
Scan it in the app →Get Spotted on your phone
Found something at a Kelleys Island thrift store? See what it goes for on eBay
Scan anything in hand to see its eBay price before you buy. Point your iPhone camera at the code.
In Kelleys Island: 1 thrift store.
Parsonage Resale Shop Thrift store
Division Street, Kelleys Island, OH 43438
Hours: 12:00-16:00
More thrift stores near Kelleys Island
Goodwill Goodwill10 mi · Sandusky
419 West Market Street, Sandusky, OH 44870
Hours: Tu-Fr 10:30-18:00; Sa 09:00-16:30
Directions · Website · +1-567-219-1569
Common questions
Is there a Goodwill in Kelleys Island, OH?
No Goodwill is listed in Kelleys Island itself. The closest is Goodwill in Sandusky, about 10 miles away.
Thrift stores in nearby cities
Sandusky (4)Huron (1)Milan (1)Vermilion (2)Norwalk (3)Lorain (2)Sheffield Lake (1)Oberlin (3)Elyria (1)Avon (1)Avon Lake (2)Northwood (1)
Store list from © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL), refreshed weekly. Missing a store or wrong hours? Fix it on OpenStreetMap and it shows here after the next refresh. · Estate and garage sales