Thrift Stores in Middletown, NY
2 stores in Middletown · 4 more within 12 miles · list updated November 8, 2026
Found something at a Middletown thrift store? See what it goes for on eBay
Scan any item in the Spotted app to see what it's listed for on eBay before you buy it. Estate sales, garage sales and store clearance near you are on the same map.
Scan it in the app →Get Spotted on your phone
Found something at a Middletown thrift store? See what it goes for on eBay
Scan anything in hand to see its eBay price before you buy. Point your iPhone camera at the code.
In Middletown: 1 salvation army, 1 thrift store.
The Salvation Army Salvation Army
237 Wickham Avenue, Middletown, NY 10940
Hours: Mo-Sa 10:00-19:00
Directions · +1-800-728-7825
Nearby, a short drive from Middletown
Your Treasure Shop Thrift store2 mi · Cuddebackville
Cuddebackville, NY 12729
Directions · +1-845-343-8443
Red Door Thrift Shop Thrift store6 mi · Goshen
36 Saint John Street, Goshen, NY 10924
Directions · Website · +1-845-294-5521
Red Door Thrift Shop Thrift store6 mi · Goshen
36 Saint John Street, Goshen, NY 10924
Directions · +1 845 294 5521
More places to source in Middletown
- Estate and garage sales in Middletown this weekend (1 sale coming up)
- Flea markets and antique malls near Middletown (2 places)
Common questions
Is there a Goodwill in Middletown, NY?
No Goodwill is listed in Middletown itself.
Thrift stores in nearby cities
Cuddebackville (2)Goshen (2)Port Jervis (2)Beacon (1)Hughsonville (1)Poughkeepsie (1)Fishkill (1)Baldwin Place (1)Mohegan Lake (1)Nyack (1)Boiceville (1)Glasco (2)
Store list from © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL), refreshed weekly. Missing a store or wrong hours? Fix it on OpenStreetMap and it shows here after the next refresh. · Estate and garage sales