Thrift Stores in Fayetteville, NY
2 stores in Fayetteville · 15 more within 12 miles · list updated November 8, 2026
Found something at a Fayetteville thrift store? See what it goes for on eBay
Scan any item in the Spotted app to see what it's listed for on eBay before you buy it. Estate sales, garage sales and store clearance near you are on the same map.
Scan it in the app →Get Spotted on your phone
Found something at a Fayetteville thrift store? See what it goes for on eBay
Scan anything in hand to see its eBay price before you buy. Point your iPhone camera at the code.
In Fayetteville: 1 thrift store, 1 consignment.
Encore Thrift Shop Thrift store
118 Mill Street, Fayetteville, NY 13066
Hours: Tu-Fr 11:00-16:00; Sa 11:00-14:00
Directions · Website · +1-315-637-6133
Nearly New Consignment Shop Consignment
115 Chapel Street, Fayetteville, NY 13066
Hours: Tu-Fr 10:00-17:00; Sa 10:00-15:00
Nearby, a short drive from Fayetteville
Thrifty Shopper Thrift store4 mi · East Syracuse
112 East Manlius Street, East Syracuse, NY 13057
Hours: Mo-Sa 10:00-21:00; Su 11:00-18:00
Directions · Website · +1-315-432-8560
The Salvation Army Salvation Army5 mi · Syracuse
Erie Boulevard East, Syracuse, NY 13224
Hours: Mo-Sa 09:00-21:00
3fifteen Thrift store5 mi · Syracuse
3525 James Street, Syracuse, NY 13206
Hours: Mo-Sa 10:00-20:00; Su 11:00-18:00
Directions · Website · +1-315-299-9260
The Salvation Army Thrift Store Salvation Army7 mi · Chittenango
205 Tuscarora Road, Chittenango, NY 13037
Hours: Mo-Sa 10:00-19:00
Habitat for Humanity ReStore Habitat ReStore8 mi · Syracuse
514 West Genesee Street, Syracuse, NY 13204
Hours: Tu-Sa 09:00-16:30
Directions · Website · +1 315-475-9172
Thrifty Shopper Thrift store8 mi · Syracuse
436 West Seneca Turnpike, Syracuse, NY 13207
Hours: Mo-Sa 10:00-18:00; Su 11:00-18:00
Directions · Website · +1-315-492-0802
Yellow Brick Thrift Thrift store8 mi · Chittenango
1001 East Genesee Street, Chittenango, NY 13037
Goodwill Goodwill9 mi · Syracuse
Onondaga Boulevard, Syracuse, NY 13089
Hours: Mo-Sa 09:00-21:00; Su 10:00-19:00
CNY Commerce Thrift store9 mi · Jamesville
2771 Sweet Road, Jamesville, NY 13078
Hours: "by appointment"
Directions · Website · +1-315-409-9113
North Syracuse Consignment Shop Consignment9 mi · North Syracuse
3728 Brewerton Road, North Syracuse, NY 13212
Palm Market Thrift store10 mi · Liverpool
680 Old Liverpool Road, Liverpool, NY 13088
Hours: Mo-Fr 10:00-21:00; Sa 09:00-21:00; Su 11:00-18:00
Directions · Website · +1-315-451-2253
Thrify Shopper Thrift store10 mi · Syracuse
2214 West Genesee Street, Syracuse, NY 13219
Hours: Mo-Sa 10:00-20:00; Su 11:00-18:00
More places to source in Fayetteville
Common questions
Is there a Goodwill in Fayetteville, NY?
No Goodwill is listed in Fayetteville itself. The closest is Goodwill in Syracuse, about 9 miles away.
Thrift stores in nearby cities
East Syracuse (1)Syracuse (7)Chittenango (2)Jamesville (1)North Syracuse (1)Clay (1)Cicero (1)Liverpool (3)Baldwinsville (1)Clinton (1)New Hartford (1)Utica (2)
Store list from © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL), refreshed weekly. Missing a store or wrong hours? Fix it on OpenStreetMap and it shows here after the next refresh. · Estate and garage sales