Thrift Stores in & Near New Providence, NJ
1 store in New Providence · 17 more within 12 miles · list updated November 5, 2026
Found something at a New Providence thrift store? See what it goes for on eBay
Scan any item in the Spotted app to see what it's listed for on eBay before you buy it. Estate sales, garage sales and store clearance near you are on the same map.
Scan it in the app →This week at Goodwill near New Providence
- Goodwill Insider loyalty program · members
From Goodwill NYNJ (their site). Promos vary by store; check before you go.
In New Providence: 1 consignment.
More thrift stores near New Providence
Junior League of Summit Thrift store3 mi · Summit
37 Deforest Avenue, Summit, NJ 07901
Hours: Tu, Fr-Sa 09:00-13:00; We-Th 15:00-19:00
Directions · Website · +1-908-273-7349
Salvation Army Salvation Army6 mi · Plainfield
615 Watchung Avenue, Plainfield, NJ 07060
Directions · +1 908 756 2595
2nd Avenue Thrift Superstore Thrift store6 mi · Vauxhall
2661 Morris Avenue, Vauxhall, NJ 07083
Hours: Mo-Su 09:00-21:00
Directions · +1-908-258-7180
Market Street Mission Thrift Shop Thrift store7 mi · Cedar Knolls
25, Cedar Knolls, NJ 07927
Directions · +1-973-538-0427
myUnique Thrift store9 mi · South Plainfield
698 Oak Tree Avenue, South Plainfield, NJ 07080
Hours: Mo-Sa 10:00-20:00; Su 11:00-17:00
Inspirations Thrift store10 mi · Rahway
1550 US 1, Rahway, NJ 07065
Hours: Mo-Sa 09:00-19:00; Su 10:00-16:00
Directions · Website · +1-848-666-7901
Willing Hearts Thrift store12 mi · Caldwell
491 Bloomfield Avenue, Caldwell, NJ 07008
Hours: We-Sa 10:00-17:00; Tu 08:00-20:00
Directions · Website · +1 973-226-7488
Common questions
Is there a Goodwill in New Providence, NJ?
No Goodwill is listed in New Providence itself. The closest is Goodwill in Springfield, about 4 miles away.
Thrift stores in nearby cities
Summit (1)Madison (1)Short Hills (1)Springfield (1)Watchung (1)Garwood (1)Kenilworth (1)Vauxhall (1)Plainfield (1)Cranford (3)Cedar Knolls (2)South Plainfield (1)
Store list from © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL), refreshed weekly. Missing a store or wrong hours? Fix it on OpenStreetMap and it shows here after the next refresh. · Estate and garage sales